Politics
LeBlanc Backs Carney on Why Trade Talks Collapsed
Trade Minister Dominic LeBlanc told MPs Carney’s account of why August trade talks collapsed was correct, even as the U.S. disputes it. Charette said to prepare for lasting tariffs.
Canada-U.S. Trade Minister Dominic LeBlanc told a House of Commons committee Tuesday that Prime Minister Mark Carney’s account of why trade talks collapsed in August was correct, even as U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer disputes it. LeBlanc said he would not discuss details of the negotiations, the Canadian Press reported.
LeBlanc appeared before the Standing Committee on International Trade with Janice Charette, Canada’s chief trade negotiator to the United States. MPs pressed them on the August breakdown, Ottawa’s counter-tariffs, whether tariff-free trade is still the goal, and the government’s growing trade with China.
Key Takeaways
- LeBlanc said the prime minister was “absolutely correct” that last-day U.S. demands would have limited Canada’s ability to sign trade deals with other countries.
- He said Canada’s counter-tariffs were meant to protect Canadian industries, not to change Washington’s behaviour, and Charette said Canada should prepare for a world where some U.S. tariffs stay.
- LeBlanc declined to confirm that a USMCA clause on non-market economies was behind the dispute, and did not commit to briefing Parliament before a deal is signed.
Carney’s three reasons and Greer’s replies
After talks ended in late August, Carney said Washington had sought to restrict Canada’s ability to strike other trade deals, to limit protections for French language and culture, and to leave medium- and heavy-duty trucks out of tariff relief, according to the Epoch Times. Greer replied that language and culture were never a “red line,” and said the U.S. request on other trade deals was about stopping third countries from dumping steel into Canada that could then reach the U.S. at a preferential rate.
LeBlanc said at the time that the U.S. was withdrawing its positions on discoverability and labelling, and at the committee he said that issue is resolved. On the trade-deals point, he said Carney was “absolutely correct to say on that last day” that the U.S. introduced elements that would have limited Canada’s ability to enter free trade agreements with other countries. “Certain sectors were identified by the Americans,” he said, and Carney concluded that it was a matter of Canada’s sovereign interest.
The non-market economy question
A Conservative MP asked whether the dispute was tied to the USMCA clause that discourages members from signing free trade agreements with non-market economies and lets the other parties withdraw if they do. LeBlanc said the MP was assuming that context. “The prime minister didn’t talk about that publicly and neither are we,” he said. Greer has cited the same USMCA provision publicly, according to the Epoch Times. LeBlanc also said he and Greer have agreed not to discuss their private conversations publicly.
Tariffs, counter-tariffs and the goal
Asked what evidence there is that Canada’s counter-tariffs changed U.S. behaviour, LeBlanc said the measures were adopted to protect workers and sectors that faced an uneven playing field, not to change another government’s behaviour. As of late August, the U.S. had imposed 50 per cent tariffs on US$20 billion of Canadian exports, while Ottawa planned tariffs on $27.6 billion of U.S. goods starting Sept. 8, according to the Epoch Times.
Asked whether tariff-free trade is still the goal, Charette said the USMCA is “the very best trade agreement in the world” and that Canada would like to return to it. She added that Canada must “prepare ourselves for a world” in which that is not possible, and said the aim is the lowest tariff rate on the narrowest basket of goods with the most preferential access. She said the U.S. is reordering its trade relationships with every country.
China, Mexico and Parliament
A Conservative MP from Calgary asked why the government had chosen Chinese steel and autos over North American partners. LeBlanc said the government has not prioritized China over the United States and that it is “not sort of an either-or choice.” Carney has also said Canada could turn to Chinese automakers if U.S. talks fail, the Canadian Press reported.
Conservative MP Stephanie Kusie said Mexico has held three bilateral rounds with the U.S. this year, in May, June and July, with a fourth planned, and criticized the government for not setting aside U.S. rhetoric to get a deal. LeBlanc said the U.S.-Mexico relationship is different from the Canada-U.S. one but shares many common elements. He said the most constructive way to reach a deal is “precisely not to pay attention to a particular weekend television show in the United States or a particular minister.”
On whether the government will brief Parliament before a deal is signed, LeBlanc said he and Charette have made themselves available to brief MPs and senators and are “happy to collaborate,” but he did not commit to a briefing before signing.
Trending News:
Navarro Warns Canada on China as Carney Eyes Auto Options
Why Doesn’t Canada Have a U.S. Trade Deal Yet? Why is Mark Carney Stalling?
-
News10 months ago
China-Based Billionaire Singham Allegedly Funding America’s Radical Left
-
Politics9 months ago
Ilhan Omar’s Connections to Convicted Somali Fraudsters Surface
-
Politics10 months ago
CNN Delivers Stark Reality Check to Democrats Over Voter ID
-
Politics8 months ago
Rep. Ilhan Omar Faces Heat as Minnesota Voters Seek Change
-
Politics9 months ago
Trump Approval Rating (February 2026 Poll Results, Approve vs Disapprove)
-
United States10 months ago
China Backed US Billionaire Singham Allegedly Funding of Anti-ICE Protests
-
Politics8 months ago
NATO Chief Says 22 Nations Working With US to Keep the Strait of Hormuz Open
-
Politics9 months ago
Calls Mount to Expel Rep. Ilhan Omar from Congress