Connect with us

Politics

Poilievre Takes Aim at Carney on Stellantis, Telus, Brazil

Pierre Poilievre criticized more public money for Stellantis, a $560 million Brazil forest pledge and Carney’s comments on telecom competition amid the Quebecor-Telus proposal.

Leyna Wong

Published

on

Poilievre Takes Aim at Carney

Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre, speaking to reporters on Parliament Hill on Nov. 20, weighed in on Quebecor’s proposed takeover of Telus and Prime Minister Mark Carney’s comments on competition, The Canadian Press reported. In the remarks reviewed for this article, he also criticized public money for Stellantis and a roughly $560 million pledge for a Brazil-led forest fund.

Poilievre said Stellantis “should deliver for the money it already got,” called Carney’s competition comments “ridiculous,” and said any telecom merger should be judged on whether it lowers prices for consumers.

Key Takeaways

  • Poilievre opposed giving Stellantis more public money and called for lower taxes on businesses that create and keep jobs in Canada, including removal of the industrial carbon tax.
  • He said Carney was wrong to suggest that fewer competitors can help prices, and said he would judge the proposed Quebecor-Telus deal on whether it lowers consumer costs.
  • He argued that spending abroad, including the Brazil forest pledge, makes Canada “more dependent” and not more independent.

Stellantis and the Brampton plant

Stellantis announced on Nov. 9 that it will sell its Brampton, Ont., assembly plant to the defence contractor Roshel. Industry Minister Melanie Joly wrote to the company on Nov. 12, alleging that it breached a 2022 funding agreement and giving it 30 days to fix the problems or face a possible demand for repayment, Money.ca reported. Ottawa had committed up to $529 million under that agreement, and Stellantis has offered to repay $24 million.

Poilievre said the company should not receive more money. “Why would we shovel even more money into the coffers of a company that refused to deliver on the commitment it made the last time it got money?” he asked, adding that a further request would be “blackmail on top of bribery.” Money.ca reported that he has also called for the government to sue Stellantis to recover tax dollars.

On Nov. 20, Premier Doug Ford called a meeting with Stellantis officials “challenging but productive,” according to CTV News. Ford said the company pointed to U.S. tariffs and Canadian emissions costs as reasons for its position, and urged Ottawa to remove those costs. CTV reported that the federal response had moved “from threats to offers of more money,” and that a source said Ottawa was not expected to lift the carbon price. None of the reports reviewed said Stellantis had formally asked for more public money. For background on the sector, see our report on Carney’s comments on Chinese automakers.

The Brazil pledge

Poilievre said giving “a half billion dollars to Brazil” does not diversify Canada’s trade away from the United States. “Throwing away billions of dollars on overseas on foreign interests does not make us more independent,” he said. “It makes us more dependent.” He pointed to homelessness and food bank lines at home. Our earlier article covers the clash between Poilievre and the Liberals over the $560 million pledge, which CP24 reported Carney announced on Nov. 15.

Carney’s oligopoly remarks

At a Nov. 18 news conference in Shenzhen, China, Carney was asked about Quebecor’s bid for Telus. MobileSyrup reported that he said an oligopoly “can lead to more competition” with fewer players under certain market conditions. It reported that he declined to endorse the proposal, pointed to the CRTC and competition regulators, and said there has been improvement on high bills but “we need more improvement.”

Poilievre said he had never seen an economist anywhere in the world argue that less competition ultimately brings prices down. “He’s been wrong about almost every economic issue,” he said, citing carbon taxes, pipelines and money printing. Those are his characterizations; Carney’s reported remarks were about competition with fewer players.

The Quebecor-Telus proposal

Quebecor publicly unveiled its proposal to buy Telus on Nov. 16, valuing the company at about $31 billion excluding debt, according to MobileSyrup. Telus has not accepted, and its board has raised concerns about price, debt and the difficulty of regulatory approval. NDP Leader Avi Lewis has urged the government to reject the deal.

Poilievre said Conservatives have not seen the proposal, that shareholders have not approved it, and that the Competition Bureau has not had a chance to investigate. “We will judge this decision based on one principle,” he said. “Will it lower cost for consumers? Yes or no.”

What to watch

Watch for Stellantis’s response to Joly’s 30-day notice, which expires around Dec. 12, and for any federal move on emissions costs for automakers. On telecom, watch whether Telus’s board engages with Quebecor and how the Competition Bureau and CRTC respond. For trade context, see our report on the interim U.S. trade deal.

Leyna Wong writes about health with a friendly, clear voice that helps readers feel at ease. She has a sharp eye for facts and breaks down hard topics into plain language. Leyna checks sources and keeps her advice practical so readers can trust what they find. She covers everything from nutrition to mental health, sharing tips that fit into real life.

Continue Reading

Get 30 Days Free

Create Super Content

Flight Buddies Needed

Trending